tesla ethical issues 2020randy edwards obituary
The company wants everyone to work hard, love what they do and enjoy themselves. Tesla Motors has responded to a magazine article that questioned the all-electric carmaker's ethics in handling the aftermath of the first recorded fatal crash involving a Model S sedan using. Register a free Taylor & Francis Online account today to boost your research and gain these benefits: Ethical issues in focus by the autonomous vehicles industry, Engineering Systems & Services, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands, Dataset Ethical Issues in Focus by the Autonomous Vehicles Industry, Autonomous vehicles: Challenges, opportunities, and future implications for transportation policies, Autonomous vehicles require socio-political acceptance An empirical and philosophical perspective on the problem of moral decision making, Life and death decisions of autonomous vehicles, The social dilemma of autonomous vehicles, The trolley, the bull bar, and why engineers should care about the ethics of autonomous cars [point of view], Self-driving cars: Ethical responsibilities of design engineers, Self-driving cars and engineering ethics: The need for a system level analysis, Institute of Transportation Studies & Policy Institute for Energy, Environment, and the Economy, Responsibility and the moral phenomenology of using self-driving cars, Artificial intelligence, responsibility attribution, and a relational justification of explainability, Privacy implications and liability issues of autonomous vehicles, Autonomous vehicles and avoiding the trolley (dilemma): vehicle perception, classification, and the challenges of framing decision ethics, Regulating autonomous systems: Beyond standards, From here to autonomy: Lessons learned from humanautomation research, When AI ethics goes astray: A case study of autonomous vehicles, Incorporating ethics into artificial intelligence, Preparing a nation for autonomous vehicles: opportunities, barriers and policy recommendations, Autonomous vehicles' disengagements: Trends, triggers, and regulatory limitations, Examining accident reports involving autonomous vehicles in California, Public health, ethics, and autonomous vehicles, What does matter? Only published scientific documents with available full text written in English language and addressing the moral or ethics dimensions of automated driving systems were considered eligible for this study. Using the combination of keywords Autonomous Vehicles AND Ethics; Autonomous Vehicles AND Moral; Self driving AND Ethics; Self driving AND Moral; Driverless AND Ethics; and Driverless AND Moral in Scopus and Google Scholar (in the latter only records within the 20152020 timeframe in the first five pages of the database were considered), 715 records were identified. Specifically, the EPA is seeking details about how Tesla handles "surface coating" of its vehicles. Musk seeks out smart and motivated people and holds them accountable. Companies have stated the need for clear rules to be set in advance (It is necessary to put legal frameworks in place in order to clarify where the responsibility lies in case of the occurrence of an accident after the realisation of fully automated driving Honda Sustainability Report 2015 Honda, Citation2015), while also presenting technical solutions aimed at expediting investigations, such as the use of a black-box akin to a flight recorder designed to store accident data, or responsibility algorithms based on mathematical models (With regard to liability issues a black-box is required that stores certain data necessary to sort out accident liability which can contribute towards allocating responsibility between human and machine when accidents happen BMW Sustainable Value Report 2016 (BMW, Citation2016); What will happen when a collision occurs? Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. Tesla is now the world's most valuable car manufacturer as shares surge over 400 per cent, but tech companies like Elon Musk's have big questions to answer over ethically sourced materials. 3099067 Shashua & Shalev-Shwartz, Citation2017). Baffour-Awuah, D. (2020). We removed one ethical issue (field-specific deliberations) as well as all AI references as we focus on the AV as a particular AI-powered technology. The Tesla CEOs anti-lockdown cause has won the support of Donald Trump. awareness or knowledge of the agent regarding the action (Coeckelbergh, Citation2020); and liability is legal or financial responsibility (Collingwood, Citation2017). Waymo has ordered a fleet of self-driving Chrysler Pacifica plug-in hybrid minivans and Jaguar I-Pace SUVs. It should be noted that, even when we found quite comprehensive accounts on particular ethical issues, the narratives in the AV reports are consistently pragmatic and oriented towards technical solutions. She said she took Musk at his word in early May but thinks her job was threatened because she did so and then spoke out. Our research highlights how Tesla has been fined for several air quality violations, has been criticised for alleged child labour involvement in its supply chain, its presence in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region of China, very high directors pay, and poor tax conduct. In late April, Musk went on an erratic tweetstorm that culminated in his writing FREE AMERICA NOW in response to widespread stay-at-home orders. ); Over time, though, Guardian capability will grow steadily as technology improves, with a goal of creating a vehicle never responsible for a crash regardless of errors made by a human driver Toyota, Citationn.d.). Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine. German authorities also fined Tesla 12 million euros for allegedly failing to fulfill their obligations around taking back old batteries from customers. And finally we reflected on the theoretical propositions and main empirical findings related to the ethical issues which are the focus points of this research. As a consequence, our analysis of these reports which uses a combination of manual reading and text mining, risks conflating different meanings attached to the same vocabulary. Ethical issues in AV industry. Chinese regulators reprimand Tesla over growing complaints about its cars. The essence of Corporate Social ResponsibilityCase Study of Tesla Inc. He launched into an expletive-laden rant on the companys earnings call the next day, labeling quarantine measures fascist and demanding that politicians return peoples freedom. Musk defiantly reopened the factory in early May, winning President Trumps support as he bucked the countys orders once more. Carlos, there is no need to feel that you are going to lose your job, wrote Vince Woodard, Teslas acting human resources director, in a May email to Gabriel viewed by The Post. it is stated that their Responsibility-Sensitive-Safety system will always brake in time to avoid a collision with a pedestrian unless the pedestrian is running super-humanly fast (Shashua & Shalev-Shwartz, Citation2017). We first provide an overview of the ethics narratives both in the scientific literature and industry reports. Tesla is forced to call off plans to reopen its plant on 4 May. By closing this message, you are consenting to our use of cookies. By providing the super-humanly fast runner illustration, Intel is not only emphasising that their AV will not be responsible for a collision with a pedestrian, but it is also promoting trust in their technology. To become an Amazon Clinic patient, first you sign away some privacy, Elon Musk describes Starship flight as roughly what I expected, How Mark Zuckerberg broke Metas workforce, How Elon Musk knocked Teslas Full Self-Driving off course, Tesla demands removal of video of cars hitting child-size mannequins, Uber loses $2.6 billion, but its stock soared anyway, Tesla dumps Bitcoin amid pressure from factory shutdown, Teslas running Autopilot involved in 273 crashes reported since last year, Federal investigators step up probe into Tesla Autopilot crashes, Judge denies Teslas bid to move sexual harassment case to arbitration, Elon Musks Crash Course: 3 key arguments from the Tesla documentary, Elon Musk says Twitter deal is on hold, putting bid on shaky ground, Elon Musk says he would reverse Twitter ban on Donald Trump, Elon Musk found not liable in trial over Teslas SolarCity acquisition, Teslas value dropped Tuesday by more than double the cost of Twitter. What instructions will the autonomous driving computers have pre-loaded? Although blind spot detection and assistance is considered a low level automation feature, the narratives we found about this issue and its implications for pedestrians' safety are yet another substantiation of the concerns of AV companies about extreme traffic situations (in the case of pedestrians who are occluded from the vehicle it should adjust the speed such that if a child would emerge from behind some object there would be no accident even in a worst case scenario where the pedestrian emerges from behind some sensing obstruction (e.g. Ethics and Social Responsibility Issues Related To Tesla. It has been acknowledged that using trolley cases as inputs for crash optimisation algorithms invites a myriad of criticism (Keeling, Citation2020; Nyholm & Smids, Citation2016). Tesla resumes production at the Fremont factory in defiance of the public health order. Ultimately, Gabriel and Naro, who were told they were being fired last week, believe Teslas actions were retaliation for their appearance this month at a news conference during which they spoke about conditions at the plant and their fear of returning to work. Tesla scored poorly across the remainder of our ratings that related to human and workers rights, receiving for example a worst rating for Supply Chain Management. The relevance of particular ethical issues within industry narratives requires a balance between frequency and comprehensiveness. In early 2018 engineering consultant Sandy Munro, who. Tesla, Inc.s automotive business directly addresses community issues. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Why Social Responsibility Matters to Businesses. It is clarified that accountability entails responsibility, but unlike the latter it requires explanations about actions and it cannot be shared (Mulgan, Citation2000); responsibility for an action traditionally requires at least a control condition, i.e. If you feel uncomfortable coming back to work at this time, please do not feel obligated to do so, he wrote in an email sent to the companys factory workers in early May that was viewed by The Washington Post. All Rights Reserved. The solutions advanced by companies to address this problem rely on radars and speed limitation when the visual field of the AV is obstructed. We will revisit this theory in the section below about the accountability of AVs. Other issues debated in the literature include ethical design, accountability, human meaningful control, sustainability, and privacy (Aydemir & Dalpiaz, Citation2018; Collingwood, Citation2017; Endsley, Citation2017; Hevelke & Nida-Rmelin, Citation2015; Santoni de Sio & Van den Hoven, Citation2018; Taiebat et al., Citation2018). Unlike other social and ethical issues, such as fairness or human autonomy in an AI-dominated society, safety challenges are prone to be solved by technical or engineering approaches (Hagendorff, 2020 ). The onset of autonomous driving has provided fertile ground for discussions about ethics in recent years. The facts of this case speak for themselves, he said. In the reports reviewed in this research, we found extensive safety considerations both for mundane and extreme traffic situations. Instead is uses the classic software "inbound . Choose a trusted Assignment Helper to get A+ Grades, https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/041015/why-social-responsibility-important-business.asp. (iii) Some of these extreme traffic situations will require AVs to make difficult moral decisions. Thats not us.. These concerns have prompted some workers to stay home, comforted by Teslas promises that they could keep their job without pay in the interim. Telsa, known for its Ethical code, strives to "do the right thing by engaging in activities that your household will be appreciative of." Tesla is one of the businesses that directly participate in corporate social responsibility to fulfill the stakeholders' needs. It can be done Fast & Safely!. Musk responds: Thank you!. The original list featuring 22 ethical issues in published guidelines about AI (Hagendorff, Citation2020) was adjusted for this research. Theyre saddled by the kind of promises and rushed production that get people hurt, and now hes doing it again during a pandemic.. Accountability: An ever-expanding concept? As CNBC has previously reported, the "paint shop" at Tesla's main U.S. car plant in Fremont, California, has a history of problems, including fires, improper cleaning and maintenance. Laurie Shelby, Teslas vice president for environment, health and safety, told workers in an email that there had been no workplace transmissions of the virus, though it was unknown how the exact origin of each of the cases would have been determined. In the U.S., the Environmental Protection Agency accused Tesla last week of failing to prove it is in compliance with federal emissions standards for hazardous air pollutants. (The jury ultimately ruled in Musks favor.) The Post reported earlier in June that workers at the factorys seat assembly plant were told multiple colleagues had tested positive for the coronavirus and Alameda County officials confirmed Tesla had reported coronavirus cases in Fremont. It also manufactures and sells rechargeable batteries. Ironically, some of the companys requirements have been slightlyand at times flagrantlyignored by Musk himself. It seems there is a lot more to designing autonomous systems than simply telling a self-driving car how to avoid potholes, pedestrians, and bicyclists. Did you know that with a free Taylor & Francis Online account you can gain access to the following benefits? esgSubNav, Discover more about S&P Globals offerings, Global Credit and Risk Symposium: Unlocking Possibilities, JW Marriott Sao Paulo Av. Retrieve from https://ir.tesla.com/codebusiness-conduct-and-ethics-, Murphy, C. (2019, September 25). Our review showed quite clearly that the scientific literature on AV ethics is dominated by considerations about safety and cybersecurity concerning the programming of extreme traffic situations. According to a public statement Tuesday, Tesla has notified authorities there that it wants to obtain a permit to build and operate a battery cell production facility at that new plant, currently under construction. Permission is granted subject to the terms of the License under which the work was published. Despite its limitations, the liability dilemma of the AV manufacturer sheds light on the tension between ethics and liability, which should not be ignored. In contrast, issues such as hidden costs, fairness, non-discrimination, justice, or responsible research funding were not addressed in these reports. Tesla defended itself against the allegations in a Feb. 9 blog post, saying that the DFEH lawsuit strains credulity, though its not the first racial controversy the company has endured in recent months: last fall a court ordered the company to pay $137 million to a Black contract worker over turning a blind eye to a racially hostile work environment. We also cover greenwashing, boycotts, the climbing industry, tourism and other issues. He argues that these sorts of guidelines, traditionally based on a deontological approach to ethics which relies on fixing a set of principles and maxims, should be augmented with a virtue ethics oriented approach aiming at addressing values, attitudes, and behavioural dispositions that would ultimately help professionals refraining from unethical actions (Hagendorff, Citation2020). Therefore, based on this eligibility criteria, 158 records were excluded (23 records were not published scientific documents; 47 records did not have full text available; 3 records were not written in English language; and 85 records were not about the moral or ethics dimensions of automated driving systems) thus leaving a total of 238 records for further review and analysis. The New Yorker suggests that decisions made by Germany will reverberate beyond its borders. Volkswagen is one of the largest car companies in the world, but its manufacturing prowess imposes a complicated moral responsibility on it. Usually employee handbooks are long, boring, jargon-laden and written in an authoritarian tone. The tracing condition requires the presence of at least one human agent that can understand the real capabilities of the system and bear the moral consequences of the actions of the system (Santoni de Sio & Van den Hoven, Citation2018). The defendants in the suit have committed themselves to the responsible and ethical sourcing of minerals and have policies against the use of child labor. We first reviewed the scientific literature, with the aim of outlining the AV ethics debates, by identifying the ethical issues prioritised by the scientific community and the main empirical findings. The case for killing the trolley problem (or letting it die), Paving the road ahead: Autonomous vehicles, products liability, and the need for a new approach, Autonomous vehicles: Scientometric and bibliometric review, Look ma, no hands: Wrinkles and wrecks in the age of autonomous vehicles, Ethical decision making during automated vehicle crashes. Tesla is reporting their cases among employees directly to [the Alameda County Public Health Department] as required by their Site Specific Plan, which is also a requirement for all businesses that are reopening, she said. For instance, there is still little consensus about the relevance of the trolley problem in the context of AVs (Bonnefon, Shariff, & Rahwan, Citation2019; Cunneen et al., Citation2020; Himmelreich, Citation2018; Keeling, Citation2020; Wolkenstein, Citation2018). AImotive states that test operators face their own unique challenges. Building on the notion of tracking, introduced above in the context of Meaningful Human Control, we report different approaches with respect to the authority of remote operators. Germany is the only country that has devised a legal framework for the ethical considerations it thinks should be incorporated into self-driving systems. Tesla has previously said its models are less likely to catch fire than other cars. Shares of Tesla dipped slightly in early morning trading on Wednesday after the filing. Tesla filed an objection in Germany and said that the matter should not have a material impact on Tesla's business. We discover independent ethical retailers and look closely at Amazon. Newsom announces new rules to allow some non-essential businesses, including some manufacturers, in California to reopen on 8 May. The proponents of the MME acknowledge that AV policy should not necessarily follow public expectations and preferences but they believe that such preferences should not be completely dismissed. An elevator has a rigidly defined path it must follow. Supervisors cite health privacy law in not disclosing particular cases, but workers say Tesla hasnt even described broadly how widespread the novel coronavirus is at the plant. Heres what you need to know about Arcturus. The amazing fact is that every Tesla is actually carefully constructed to last a lifetime or 100 years (!) Tesla, the renewable energy and electric car company helmed by Elon Musk, has been slow to respond to the coronavirus. Human-lovers will be disturbed to learn that dogs were more likely to be spared than criminals, the New Yorker says. 1.16, has been designated as a variant under monitoring by the World Health Organization. 2023 CNBC LLC. Accountability issues associated with AV technology have received substantial attention in the scientific literature. Six counties in the San Francisco Bay Area become the first locales in the US to order all non-essential businesses to close and require residents to shelter in place. Indeed, it has been reported that thus far governments have avoided strict measures in order to promote AV developments (Taeihagh & Lim, Citation2019). groups of search keywords organised to investigate a concept (Schuelke-Leech, Jordan, & Barry, Citation2019), associated with each ethical issue. Teslas highest paid executive received $46m according to the companys 2021 accounts. Among the reports twenty propositions, one stands out: In the event of unavoidable accident situations, any distinction based on personal features (age, gender, physical or mental constitution) is strictly prohibited.. Some workers disappear for two weeks and their peers are told theyre sick, without further explanation, another worker said.